Holiday gatherings are often made up of three central activities: indulging in delicious feasts, catching up with loved ones, and exchanging gifts.

The latter in particular can be raucous fun, whether you’re celebrating with family, friends, or even coworkers. But it can also bring the stress of finding the right present and making sure no one feels left out, let down, or bored. If you’re looking for ways to enhance your holiday gift swaps, take a closer look at four ideas that can add a little extra excitement and make them easier for everyone involved.

Pick a theme

Ideal for large groups, choosing a specific theme for your exchange can make shopping for gifts simpler since it gives each person clear parameters. The category can be anything everyone agrees on, such as ornaments, mugs, hats, or books. Whatever you lean toward, keep it broad (yet within an established price limit) to ensure that there are plenty of options to pick from, minimizing the likelihood that two people will buy the same thing.

Applying a theme is an easy way to jazz up any type of present swap, including Secret Santa or White Elephant, where participants pull a number and pick a wrapped gift in that order. If you want to make the giving more personal, ask everyone to write a short message explaining why they bought their specific item, which can help foster appreciation in the recipient for an otherwise seemingly random gift. The options for customizing and applying this idea are really endless, so get creative and see where it takes you!

Embrace regifting

Everyone has gotten a gift at one point or another that they didn’t like or simply never ended up using—and this concept capitalizes on that reality. Simply put, a regifting party involves attendees wrapping an item they received in the past and have no use for. (Just make sure it’s not from someone going to this party!) This way, no one has to exert any effort shopping or spend any money. It might still be a good idea, though, to set a price limit so one person doesn’t end up with a pair of wireless headphones and another a kitchen towel; each person should be able to gauge the cost with a quick online search.

To make things more interesting, have everyone share the story behind the regifted items either before or after they’re opened. This can lead to lots of laughs as people regale the party with tales of clueless relatives, prankster friends, and misunderstood wish lists. By not taking it too seriously and reveling in shared gifting mishaps, you can make regifting a little less taboo and turn it into a fun yet practical activity that everyone is sure to love.

Host a gift auction

For a truly unique and interactive exchange, consider organizing a gift auction. In this scenario, each participant buys and wraps a gift to bring to the party, where they are then given a set amount of “money,” like Monopoly bills or poker chips, they can use to bid on the unopened presents. The items are auctioned off one at a time, and attendees have to decide which to target based solely on factors like size or wrapping quality. Because this gift swap adds an element of strategy and competition, it’s almost guaranteed to get everyone engaged in the event, creating a livelier atmosphere that leaves them satisfied no matter what they end up with.

Stick to their wish list

One of the best ways to ensure that everyone gets something they really want is for participants to buy directly from a wish list. Several weeks before the party, have each person create one and share it with you (or whoever is organizing the event). You can then draw names to decide who is shopping for whom, sharing the appropriate list with the gift givers; a website like drawnames can help streamline this process. And if the idea of buying from a list feels too basic, invite people to add a personal touch by including a short note or a small bonus item they think the recipient would appreciate.

This exchange can be conducted entirely online, making it an optimal choice for remote coworkers or family and friend groups who may live in separate states. Set a virtual party date for opening gifts and revealing Secret Santas, and consider ways to make the event even more fun, such as by playing holiday-themed games or having everyone wear their most over-the-top holiday outfits. As a whole, this experience takes the guessing out of the gift-buying process and guarantees that everyone walks away with something they’re excited about and are sure to use.

Holiday gift swaps don’t have to be mundane or predictable. By implementing one of these more unique ideas, you can add fun, excitement, and a touch of creativity to your seasonal gatherings.